The $23 Purchase That Eliminated My $47 Yearly Expense Forever

I was just trying to stop running out of tissues every month. What happened next saved me money and freed up half my kitchen cabinet.

This is Part 2 of my Budget Sustainability Series.

I test eco-friendly switches to see if they actually save money, then break down the real costs, honest pros and cons, and give you a strategy to test it yourself.

---

You know that moment when you first move out and suddenly realize your parents were spending money on literally everything? The toilet paper, the shampoo, the endless stream of random household stuff that just appeared when you were a kid?

For me, one of the biggest shocks was tissues and paper towels. I never thought about them growing up. There was always a tissue box on the kitchen table, paper towels by the sink, and somehow they just magically refilled themselves.

My mom's house was like a tissue wonderland. Living room tissue box for movie nights and runny noses. Kitchen tissues for wiping hands after handling raw chicken. Bathroom tissues for makeup removal. Paper towels for everything else: spills, cleaning the stove, patting meat dry before seasoning, wiping down counters after cooking.

Yes, about this much paper tissues. Maybe even more.

I never questioned it. That's just how households worked, right?

My Broke Young Adult Awakening

Then I got my first apartment and my first real grocery bill.

Holy shit!!! Everything was so expensive. The rent, the utilities, the food, and then all these random recurring purchases I'd never thought about. Cleaning supplies, personal care items, and yes, tissues and paper towels.

I remembered standing in the grocery store aisle, looking at a 6 pack of tissue boxes for $12, thinking "Didn't I just buy these last month?" The paper towel section was even worse.

Those fancy quilted ones my mom always bought? $15 for a 12 pack that would last maybe six weeks in my household.

It was one of those moments where I realized I've been unconsciously hemorrhaging money on stuff I took for granted.

So I did what any broke young person does. I went to Reddit.

The Reddit Rabbit Hole

I found myself scrolling through Reddit at 2 AM, reading posts about "unnecessary recurring expenses" and "things you can eliminate from your budget." That's where I first saw someone mention switching to cotton towels for everything.

My first thought? "That sounds gross."

My second thought? "But also... interesting."

Over 80% of comments were like "This changed my life!" and the other 20% were skeptical about hygiene and convenience.

But the savings stories were compelling. People were talking about eliminating $50 to $100 annually from their budgets just by buying a bunch of cotton towels once.

I was intrigued enough to do the math for my own situation.

Breaking Down the Real Costs

Let me walk you through the calculation that convinced me to try this experiment.

What we were actually spending:

My partner and I were going through about one tissue box every two weeks, plus paper towels for kitchen tasks. I started tracking our usage for a week and was honestly shocked.

Below were Our daily tissue and paper towel usage:

• 2 to 3 tissues for hand cleaning after cooking (we cook a lot)

• 1 to 2 paper towels for wiping down the table after meals

• 2 to 3 paper towels for kitchen cleanup (spills, counters, etc.)

• 1 to 2 tissues for patting meat dry before cooking

• Random usage for runny noses, cleaning mirrors, whatever

Total: About 10 pieces of paper per day, between tissues and paper towels.

The math: 10 × 365 = 3,650 pieces annually

At roughly $0.013 per tissue (Amazon bulk pricing), that's about $47 per year Plus the inconvenience of constantly running out and having to restock

The cotton towel alternative: 6 premium cotton kitchen towels: About $24 upfront

Break even point: 1,756 pieces of paper (which equal to just about 5.8 months of usage, for a family of 2 adults)

After that: Pure savings for the 5+ years those towels would last.

Maybe even longer. I’m conservative with my assumptions here.

The math was compelling, but I was still skeptical about the practical side.

The Test Run

I decided to try it gradually. Instead of throwing out all our paper products immediately, I bought three cotton towels and designated them for specific uses:

One towel for hand cleaning and table wiping.

One darker towel for kitchen cleanup and counter wiping.

One dedicated towel for meat prep and messier cooking tasks.

For the first week, I used cotton towels during the day and kept paper products as backup for when I forgot or felt weird about it.

Honestly? By day three, I preferred the towels.

They absorbed spills better than paper towels. They felt nicer on my hands. They didn't leave that weird papery residue that cheap paper towels sometimes do. And there was something satisfying about not generating a small pile of used paper every time I cooked dinner.

Six Months Later: The Honest Review

What I genuinely love:

Never running out. There's something so freeing about crossing tissues off your shopping list forever. No more panicked trips back to the store. No more awkward moments when you're hosting and realize you're out of paper towels.

The convenience factor surprised me most. I used to keep backup tissue boxes in this tiny cabinet above my fridge that I could barely reach. Now that entire space is free for actual food storage.

The towels work better for most tasks. They're more absorbent, they don't fall apart when wet, and they feel better on your skin. My partner, who's particular about textures, actually prefers them for drying hands.

The realistic downsides:

You do have to wash them. For the cleaner towel, I throw them in with my weekly laundry, so it's not really extra work, but it's something to remember. And for the dirty one, I just put on my gloves, and hand wash them. 2 towel took me about 5 - 10 minutes at best to wash.

There's a mental adjustment period. For about a month, I'd automatically reach for the tissue box that wasn't there anymore. Old habits die hard.

Some things still need paper products. I kept a small pack of paper towels for truly gross cleanups (cleaning up after pets, dealing with raw meat packaging, etc.), but we use maybe one roll every few months now.

Unexpected benefits:

My kitchen looks less cluttered without tissue boxes everywhere. There's something aesthetically pleasing about having neat stacks of clean towels instead of cardboard boxes scattered around.

I feel weirdly proud every time I reach for a towel instead of generating waste. It's like a tiny daily reminder that I'm making a good choice for both my wallet and the environment.

Cotton towel can be very beautiful too.

The financial relief is real. $47 might not sound like much, but when you're budgeting carefully, eliminating any recurring expense feels like a victory.

The Environmental Math That Actually Shocked Me

I wasn't thinking about environmental impact when I made this switch—I was just trying to save money. But when I calculated what we were actually preventing, the numbers were more significant than expected.

Our daily usage of 10 pieces of paper products translates to some measurable environmental impacts:

• Weight and waste: One sheet of tissue paper typically weighs around 0.5 grams, while a single paper towel weighs about 1.2 grams. Based on our usage (roughly 5 tissues and 5 paper towel pieces daily), we were creating about 8.5 grams of paper waste daily, or 3.1 kg (6.8 pounds) annually.

• Manufacturing water footprint: One ton of paper towels requires an estimated 17,000 gallons of water to produce. That's about 8.5 gallons per pound. For our 6.8 pounds of annual paper product consumption, that represents approximately 58 gallons of water used in manufacturing.

• Carbon footprint: Using two standard paper towels has a carbon footprint of just over 15 grams of CO2. That breaks down to about 7.75 grams of CO2 per towel. For our household's annual usage, that's roughly 14 kg (31 pounds) of CO2 emissions from paper towel and tissue production.

The 5-Year Impact

Over five years, our paper product habit would generate:

• 34 pounds of paper waste

• 290 gallons of water consumption for manufacturing

• 155 pounds of CO2 emissions

Cotton Towels: The Alternative Impact

Six cotton towels require water and energy to manufacture and wash, but the lifecycle impact is much lower:

• One-time manufacturing: The water to grow and process the cotton for these six towels is an estimated 40-60 gallons. This is a one-time cost.

• Annual washing impact: Since the towels are washed with existing laundry loads, the additional water used is negligible. We can assume the water cost is absorbed by the laundry that would be done anyway. The only additional water cost would be for an extra rinse cycle or a slight increase in load size, which is minimal.

Net Environmental Savings over 5 Years

• 34 pounds less waste going to landfills

• 230-250 gallons of water saved

• Significantly reduced CO2 emissions from avoided paper manufacturing

Why This Works When Other Eco Swaps Don't?

I've tried other environmentally friendly switches before. Some worked (switching to bar soap), some didn't (reusable straws that I constantly forgot), and some had major learning curves (menstrual cups, which I eventually loved but took months to adjust to).

But this towel switch is different because it's immediately better in almost every way. More effective, more convenient, saves money, and helps the environment. There's no compromise or adjustment period required.

It's not like buying an expensive eco friendly product that makes you feel virtuous but breaks your budget. This is a one time purchase that improves your daily life while accidentally solving multiple problems.

Want to Try It?

If you're curious about making this switch, here's what I'd recommend:

Step 1: Start very small

Buy 2 to 3 cotton kitchen towels and test them for your most common paper towel uses. Live with them for a week and see how it feels.

Step 2: Calculate your actual usage.

You might be surprised by how many paper products your household goes through. Track it for a few days.

Think about your specific needs. Do you have small kids? Are you messy cooks? Do you entertain a lot? The more you currently use paper products, the more you'll save.

Step 3: Have Fun Saving & Don't Overthink It

This isn't about becoming zero waste overnight. It's about finding one recurring expense you can eliminate while improving your daily experience.

For me, this switch ranks among my top adulting discoveries. Right up there with learning to cook properly, investing in good kitchen knives, and figuring out how to budget without feeling deprived.

Sometimes the best life hacks are hiding in plain sight, being discussed by broke people on the internet while companies try to sell you more expensive alternatives.